AGAIN (for the second time today ) I totally agree with that statement. This is probably not something that was a first time occurrence. This is most likely someone who is a miserable person around the office in general, someone who people avoid on a daily basis, the downer that finds fault with everything anyone does, the one people avoid in the lunch room, we have one in my office, shes a miserable b!tch and has hate in her heart (in my office, this person actually physically threatened someone). But she does do her job well, albeit in a mean manner.. its a catch 22 in situations like this, employers like that she does the job well but don't like the manner in which it is done. It's hard to get rid of someone like that, they have to weigh which is the bigger loss, the person who does this kinda thing or the loss they will suffer if they fire her. Good point DoGG!